From : Paul Jorion
Object : The Euro area adjustment: about halfway there
Date : 21 June 2013 21:33:20 UTC+02:00
To : Malcolm Barr, David Mackie
Good day MM. Barr and Mackie,
I’m writing to you as I receive several mails drawing my attention to the following paragraph of your recent May report:
“The political systems in the periphery were established in the aftermath of dictatorship, and were defined by that experience. Constitutions tend to show a strong socialist influence, reflecting the political strength that left wing parties gained after the defeat of fascism. Political systems around the periphery typically display several of the following features: weak executives; weak central states relative to regions; constitutional protection of labor rights; consensus building systems which foster political clientalism; and the right to protest if unwelcome changes are made to the political status quo. The shortcomings of this political legacy have been revealed by the crisis.”
The authors of the mails I receive are under the impression that this paragraph means that you regard “constitutional protection of labor rights” and “the right to protest if unwelcome changes are made to the political status quo” as detrimental to business. There is however a wide consensus in the community that such principles are basic to democracy.
Would you be so kind as to dispel any doubts about this, so that I can reply to the mails I received?
Should I not receive any reply from you, I would conclude that you, Gentlemen, do indeed regard some basic democratic principles as detrimental to business, and mention that fact on my blog for the education of the public.
From : David Mackie
Object : Rép : The Euro area adjustment: about halfway there
Date : 23 June 2013 14:39:56 UTC+02:00
To : Paul Jorion
Thank you for your email.
The paragraph that you refer to is not intended to suggest that there is a clash between democracy and business and, in any case, we do not believe that to be the case. Rather, the paragraph is intended to be about the functioning of EMU.
There are many ways that EMU can be constructed. One of the key trade offs is between regional burden sharing and national level flexibility.
In principle, the region can choose any point on this trade off. For now, the region is moving towards a point on this trade off which involves a very modest amount of regional burden sharing and a lot of national level flexibility.
Against this background, some countries are struggling to make the adjustments required by this particular vision of EMU.
I hope this clarifies the point we were trying to make.
N. B. : Published with Mr. Mackie’s full approval.
5 responses to “A mail exchange about JP Morgan’s “The Euro area adjustment: about halfway there”, Europe Economic Research, 28 May 2013”
[…] ein Schriftwechsel mit einem Mitverfasser dieses Dokuments David Mackie […]
[…] An economist named Paul Jorion received a few alarmed emails about the report. To clear matters up, he wrote an email to the authors of the report, in which he asked: […]
I will be direct and concis (see: Les marchés financiers ont un visage; le plan de bataille des financiers). All arguments and pragmatics explanations are the trap in which we fall.
The old trick.
The thrue, it’s the JPMorgan and all.. try to guet eway from their criminals actions, and this time it’s all over the world. They trye to put their criminals actions on governemt (many politicians are working for the Big Banksters and sabote the government…An other way, it’s to put their criminals actions on the houses buyers like United State, or it’s the fault….make your choices.
The two Worst criminals are dead: Thatcher and Reagan, but 30 000 traders are in places for the next robery, and one of their chiefs live Canada for U.K. at the beginning of this years. I don’t name it because it’s easy for any one to know who.
Don’t be stupid to complain to their falls explanations.
They must be arrested first.
Two: indictment: An indictment in the common law system, is a formal accusation that a person has committed a crime. In jurisdictions that maintain the concept of felonies.
The list of their crimes is long and well documented.
Three: put in gail. A severe condamnation, an exemple for those to come.
But, a sort of significant condamnation that will dissuave any else to do so.
Am I clear enough.
It’s time to stop to be STUPID
We back in the game more powerful than ever… we are the USA! Socialism will ruin the EU, get in line stop your madness!
It is a fact that the largest part of the planet’s media is controlled by right wing capitalists. Their intention is to spread the cause of capitalism and retain the planet’s gap between wealthy and those in need. Left Insider provides left wing news from reliable news sites such as Left Futures, Red Pepper, Novara, The Canary, Buzz Feed, Left Foot Forward etc. We all have the birthright to fully exploit our own qualities and we all have the duty to help others achieve theirs.